Email updates

Keep up to date with the latest news and content from Nutrition & Metabolism and BioMed Central.

Open Access Research

The silicon supplement ‘Monomethylsilanetriol’ is safe and increases the body pool of silicon in healthy Pre-menopausal women

Ravin Jugdaohsingh*, Maio Hui, Simon HC Anderson, Stephen D Kinrade and Jonathan J Powell

Nutrition & Metabolism 2013, 10:37  doi:10.1186/1743-7075-10-37

PubMed Commons is an experimental system of commenting on PubMed abstracts, introduced in October 2013. Comments are displayed on the abstract page, but during the initial closed pilot, only registered users can read or post comments. Any researcher who is listed as an author of an article indexed by PubMed is entitled to participate in the pilot. If you would like to participate and need an invitation, please email info@biomedcentral.com, giving the PubMed ID of an article on which you are an author. For more information, see the PubMed Commons FAQ.

MMST ingestion in humans does not affect urinary volume

Ravin Jugdaohsingh   (2013-09-25 09:24)  Medical Research Council email

Dr Exley makes a perfectly valid comment concerning the role of urinary creatinine in studies with spot urines. However, to suggest that our entire study is flawed because this is not reported is as dramatic as it is erroneous. Three of the four major outcomes in our work would not have been informed by urinary creatinine. The fourth- the increase in urinary silicon/MMST concentration following supplementation �� could have been. Nonetheless, double-blind, cross-over placebo control confirmed the consistency of inter-individual urinary silicon concentrations when matched for time of day. Our previous data have shown that MMST ingestion in humans does not affect urinary volume. So, as Dr Exley states, a supplement induced change to GFR would be required to misinform this outcome. However, as we sought silicon:MMST ratios the proposed artefact would, also, have to favour urinary excretion of one form of silicon over the other (ie disproportionately). We consider this implausible and stand by our original conclusions.

Competing interests

The author�� laboratory has received research funding from the silicon supplement and food industry. The author has no competing interest.

top

Measuring the urinary excretion of silicon

Chris Exley   (2013-06-27 16:54)  Keele University email

The data in this paper relating to the urinary excretion of silicon are expressed as mg/L for point samples.

These are meaningless. Either the data should be normalised to account for differences in glomerular filtration rate and expressed per mmol creatinine or 24h urine samples should have been collected so that the data could have been expressed as per 24h.

Unfortunately data expressed in this manner are not only useless in comparisons between groups within the same study (what if MMST affected GFR?) they are also useless as they cannot be used to compare with data for urinary Si excretion in other studies.

This basic error means that this study though potentially very interesting is fundamentally flawed.

Competing interests

None declared

top

Post a comment